Valentine's gifts for girls (not candy) · Updated November 2026

Valentine's Day Gifts for Girls That Aren't Candy (Ages 7–14)

Candy is gone by February 15th. If you want a Valentine's gift for the girl in your life that lasts a little longer, here are ideas that still feel festive.

Rate My Crush crush journal for girls, Playful Edition cover
Our pick

Rate My Crush: a crush journal for girls 7–14

It's practically made for Valentine's Day, and unlike candy hearts, she'll still have it next year. It's a guided journal: every crush gets a page with a code name, a 10-category star scorecard (Smile, Eyes, Hair, Style, Personality, Humor, Kindness, How They Treat Me, Smarts/Grades and Bonus Spark, 50 stars total), a Crush Level heart meter, and prompts like "Best Thing About Them." 100 pages, 6×9.

Three covers, same prompts inside, each styled to match its cover:

Playful on AmazonMoody on AmazonFloral on Amazon

See what's inside →

Valentine's gifts for girls (not candy): 10 ideas

  1. A crush journal. About as on-theme as Valentine's gifts get.
  2. Heart-shaped or pink stationery. Cards to hand out to friends.
  3. A cozy pair of pajamas. For a Valentine's movie night at home.
  4. Friendship bracelet supplies. Galentine's gifts for her friends.
  5. A Valentine's craft kit. Make cards, garlands or decorations together.
  6. A pink or red hair accessory set. For a festive school day.
  7. A book about friendship. Something sweet to read.
  8. A fun mug with a note. Fill it with something small.
  9. A baking kit. Heart cookies, together.
  10. A handwritten letter from you. The one she'll keep.
Tip: pair the journal with a set of gel pens. It doesn't come with pens.

Questions

What's a good Valentine's gift for a daughter that isn't candy?

Something she'll keep: a journal, pajamas, a craft kit or a handwritten letter. Rate My Crush is a crush journal for girls 7–14, so it's about as on-theme as Valentine's gifts get.

Is Rate My Crush appropriate for Valentine's Day?

Yes. It's a lighthearted, age-appropriate journal for girls 7–14 to rate their crushes with stars and a heart meter.

More gift guides

Gift Ideas for a 10-Year-Old Girl (That She'll Actually Use)Thoughtful, fun gift ideas for a 10-year-old girl: screen-free, creative and age-appropriate picks, plus a cru…Stocking Stuffers for Tween Girls (Ages 8–14) That Aren't Just CandySmall, fun stocking stuffer ideas for tween girls ages 8 to 14, from gel pens to a crush journal she'll keep f…Fun Aunt Gift Guide: Gifts for Your Niece (Ages 7–14)Gift ideas for your niece ages 7 to 14 from the fun aunt: things her parents wouldn't think of, including a cr…Screen-Free Gifts for Tween Girls She'll Actually WantScreen-free gift ideas for tween girls ages 8 to 14 that compete with a phone: journals, crafts, games and a c…Gifts for Your Granddaughter (Ages 7–14) From a Cool GrandmaGift ideas for a granddaughter ages 7 to 14: fun, thoughtful picks that make Grandma the cool one, including a…Sleepover Ideas for Tween Girls: Activities, Snacks and GamesEasy sleepover ideas for tween girls ages 8 to 14: activities, games and snack ideas, plus a crush journal tha…